I just got done reading a fantastic article over on FreshDV. Kendal explores a lot of things I’ve thought but never been able to quite put into words. In addition, he provides some inspirational backup in the form of quotes from fantastic cinematographers. Go read it.
If it pisses you off then you need to go out and prove him wrong.
Of course, by proving him wrong – you’ll likely end up proving him right.
The central premise is that just because you have good equipment, that doesn’t make you a filmmaker. Just because you make pretty pictures, that doesn’t make you a cinematographer. Making pretty pictures with good gear isn’t enough – you have to practice your craft make good, defendable decisions, and understand why the decision you made work in that specific situation.
There is lots of room for experimentation, montages, test footage, etc in the world Kendal describes. Just don’t (always) call those things “art.”
When I teach at both the high school and college level, I always ask the kids “What prevents you from producing films at the highest level?” I consistently get two answers:
- Not enough time
- Our equipment sucks
The not enough time argument is legitimate, I tell them. While there is NEVER enough time to do everything you want when you are a filmmaker – the pressures of student life make those time constraints even more restrictive. So #1 – check… not much we can do about that.
However – the second reason – Once I get that answer, I call bullshit and show them this:
Ayz Waraich (@ayz on Twitter) is a fantastic up-and-coming filmmaker. He is consistently honing and improving his craft. He understands how his choices affect the story. Everything on the screen helps move the script forward. He is humble and thoughtful, eager to learn, and he shot that film on what is essentially a Sony Handycam.
It ain’t the gear, folks. Its the person (or more often the team) who wields it.
So go out and prove Kendal wrong. Go make a film and learn from it. Then make another (and learn from it). And another (and learn from it). And another…
Written by Brent Altomare